Free domestic shipping on orders over $50!

High Payoff Eyeshadow

A colorful range of pressed single-pan eyeshadows featuring highly pigmented, long-lasting and blendable colors that glide on like butter with various finishes. Whether you want foil, matte, metallic or vegan eyeshadow, we've got something fierce for you! All are cruelty-free and made in the USA.

Angel Face

$5.59 $6.99

Bay Breeze

$5.59 $6.99

Birthday Suit

$5.59 $6.99

Black Moon

$5.59 $6.99

Blue Magic

$5.59 $6.99

Brick

$5.59 $6.99

Chameleon

$5.59 $6.99

Champagne Life

$5.59 $6.99

Chocolate

$5.59 $6.99

Cinnamon Lust

$5.59 $6.99

Clutch Pearls

$5.59 $6.99

Date Night

$5.59 $6.99

Dethrone

$5.59 $6.99

Downtown

$5.59 $6.99

Empress

$5.59 $6.99

Fetish

$5.59
Sold Out $6.99

Flashing Lights

$5.59 $6.99

Flashy

$5.59 $6.99

Forbidden

$5.59 $6.99

Gingerbread

$5.59 $6.99

Glamour

$5.59 $6.99

Glisten

$5.59 $6.99

Golden Olive

$5.59 $6.99

Gumby

$5.59 $6.99

Happy Daze

$5.59 $6.99

Hot Cocoa

$5.59 $6.99

Intergalactic

$5.59 $6.99

Ladyship

$5.59 $6.99

Majestic

$5.59 $6.99

Malibu

$5.59 $6.99

Moments

$5.59 $6.99

Native

$5.59 $6.99

Passion

$5.59 $6.99

Pumpkin Pie

$5.59 $6.99

S'mores

$5.59 $6.99

Secrets

$5.59 $6.99

Short Cake

$5.59
Sold Out $6.99

Side of Olives

$5.59 $6.99

Super Star

$5.59 $6.99

Unexpected

$5.59 $6.99

Vintage

$5.59 $6.99

Who, Me?

$5.59 $6.99

Your Majesty

$5.59 $6.99

Sale

Unavailable

Sold Out